Scientists debunk myth that human brains are 'underdeveloped' at birth
Newborn babies' brains aren't "underdeveloped" compared with those of other primates at birth, a new study suggests.
In the past, scientists typically compared brain development between species by measuring how much each species' newborn brain size differs from its adult brain size. Compared with other primates, human babies' brains are significantly smaller than adults' brains. Meanwhile, newborn and adult primates have a smaller gap, which has led to the popular misconception that human newborns are "underdeveloped" in comparison.
In the new study, published Monday (Dec. 4) in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution, scientists instead considered how the absolute size of the brain at birth, compared with adulthood, has varied across mammalian evolution. They found that of all mammals with a placenta, humans showed the strongest evolutionary drive toward having a proportionally small brain size at birth. However, this is not because newborn humans' brains are smaller than expected but rather that our adult brains are dramatically larger.
In other words, we're not developmentally behind primates at birth — we just have significantly more growing to do.
"Our study shows that human brains are not substantially less developed than the brains of other primates at birth, and that they simply appear so because we normally compare brain size in newborns with adult brain size, which is much bigger in humans," lead study author Aida Gomez-Robles, an associate professor of anthropology at University College London, told Live Science in an email.
To better understand how babies' small brains stack up against other newborn animals, Gomez-Robles and colleagues analyzed brain development in modern humans, our extinct relatives the Neanderthals, and various primates, including chimpanzees, bonobos, gorillas and orangutans. In all, the study included 44 primate species, as well as dozens of additional mammals, from rodents to hooved animals and large carnivores.
They found that humans had the smallest relative brain size at birth compared with adulthood of all primates — newborn brains are less than 25% the size of adults.
Researchers believe human babies have relatively small brains because a smaller brain means childbirth is more likely to be successful.
"Classic models assume that human babies are born before they are as developed as other primates because otherwise their brains (and heads) would be too big to go through the birth canal," Gomez-Robles said. This developmental pattern ties into the fact that humans are bipedal, meaning they move around while upright on two feet, which requires a narrow pelvis compared with primates, she said.
However, human baby brains were not significantly underdeveloped compared to age-matched primates, when you consider key steps in early brain development.
When the authors focused specifically on human evolution, they found that only a few of these steps were shifted to occur after birth, instead of in the womb. These processes mainly include the insulation of nerves within brain structures, such as the hippocampus. As this makes nerves more efficient at communicating with each other, it may subsequently play a big role in driving human brain plasticity after birth, the authors wrote in the paper.
The researchers also looked at the time that human babies spend in the womb, and they found that this was no shorter than would be expected for other primates. This suggests that having relatively smaller brains as newborns is not because humans spend comparatively less time developing in the womb.
Most of the authors' results are based on estimates from mathematical models, as they were studying brain development across evolution. For example, when studying our human ancestors, they relied on approximate patterns of brain development inferred from fossilized remains.
"These estimates are valuable because they help us understand general patterns of evolution of brain development, but they are not empirical data, so they are not expected to reflect perfectly the actual ancestral values" in terms of their relative brain size over their life span, for example, Gomez-Robles said.
In future studies, the authors would like to compare these estimates with actual measurements of brain development in newborns across different species. Depending on time and resource constraints, this would be possible to a certain extent in present-day mammalian species but not in extinct species, Gomez-Robles said.
For that, they'll have to go back to the drawing board.
"The major challenge is inferring patterns of brain development in fossil hominins," our extinct ancestors, she said.
- Pregnant women who keep CrossFitting could experience fewer complications, study shows
- Five gynae red flags women should never ignore
- 5 Signs You Could Be A Narcissistic Parent
- Doctors recommend early introduction of peanuts in children's diet: Details
- How to talk to kids about divorce - it's never easy, here our experts share the best ways to do it in this age-by-age guide
- All About Testosterone in Women
- This is the reality of dealing with emotionally immature parents
- Psychologist reveals 3 tips on how to navigate parenting with a new partner - and #1 is so important
- Children become more intelligent with ‘optimal’ amount of weekly reading
- There are no winners in the breast v bottle debate
- Prunes pack a powerful punch against inflammation and bone loss in postmenopausal women
- This is exactly how your period affects your workout, according to two experts
- Scientists have finally discovered the cause of morning sickness
- What young children need
- Breakthrough menopause drug that targets key symptom given approval for use in UK
- Keeping your children safe online: All you need to know
- Dear Exhausted and Burnt Out Parents, We’re Here to Help
- How to talk to your kids about death
- Use of menopausal hormone therapy beyond age 65 years and its effects on women's health outcomes by types, routes, and doses
- Scientists debunk myth that human brains are 'underdeveloped' at birth
- What are the health risks to children who vape?
- Changes to skin during menopause explained by experts, including dry skin and acne
- Acting Tips for Kids: How to Engage Your Child Through Theater
- How to nurture creativity in your kids
- Nine things you must consider before adopting a child
- Home
- Aches and Pains
- Children - Insomnia
- New Born Babies
- Babies From 2-12 months
- Spina Bifida
- Equipment Used
- Drug Abuse
- Other Ingredients
- The Handicapped Child
- Videos
- BALANITIS - Aromachildhood
- Worms
- Corona virus and pregnancy
- Contact Us
- Essential Oils for General Purposes
- The Methods - Aromatherapy - Children-2
- Hydrolats, Essential Oil Waters, and infused Oils
- Ringworm
- The Methods - Aromatherapy - Children- 3
- Basic Care Kit - Children - Essential Oils
- Web Links
- Acne
- Adolescent Acne
- The A - Z of Conditions
- Arthritis (juvenile Rheumatoid)
- Herbal Healing Infused Oils
- The Cave Man Eating Plan
- Things To Make For Your First Aid Cabinet
- The Basic Care Kit For Children
- Verrucas and Warts
- Caring Touch Massage
- The Methods - Aromatherapy - Children
- The Methods - Aromatherapy - Children - 4
- Athlete's Foot - 2
We have 345 guests and no members online